LIVE CRYPTONEWSINSIGHTS
CryptoNewsInsightsYour source for daily crypto insights
Ethereum News

Judge Acquits MIT Brothers in $25M Ethereum MEV Case

Empty federal courtroom bench with case files in soft window light
In this article5 sections
  1. 01Key facts
  2. 02How the operation worked
  3. 03Why the judge rejected the fraud theory
  4. 04Why it matters
  5. 05What to watch

A US federal judge on Nov. 16, 2026 acquitted two MIT-educated brothers accused of pulling roughly $25 million from Ethereum trading bots in April 2023, ending the government’s first major criminal MEV prosecution without a retrial. According to Bitcoinist, US District Judge Jessica Clarke ruled that prosecutors did not establish material misrepresentation, an element wire fraud requires: the judge’s opinion cleared Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of wire fraud and related charges, one year after a jury deadlock.

Key facts

  • Judge Jessica Clarke’s Nov. 16 ruling acquits the brothers of wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering, and directs the court clerk to close the case.
  • The operation, called Omakase, generated about $25 million in roughly 12 seconds of Ethereum block production in April 2023, according to crypto.news.
  • The earlier trial ended in a mistrial in November 2025 when jurors could not reach a unanimous verdict.
  • Flashbots, the firm behind the relay software, patched its relay within 24 hours of the incident, crypto.news reported, and blacklisted the validator involved.
  • One wallet holding about $3 million of the proceeds was frozen; the brothers had moved the rest by October 2023.

How the operation worked

Prosecutors said the brothers targeted sandwich bots, programs that profit from MEV by placing trades before and after large pending purchases. The brothers spent months preparing Omakase and registered 16 Ethereum validators, per crypto.news, and in April 2023 they submitted eight bait transactions that attracted automated strategies.

Laptop showing an Ethereum wallet transaction screen in a dark home office at nightAlso readIdle Ethereum Wallet Moves $4.6M After 11 Years

When one of their validators was chosen to build a block, they exploited a relay vulnerability linked to MEV-Boost, an open-source tool Flashbots introduced in 2022. A digitally signed block header carried two fields set to zero, describing an invalid block, and the relay disclosed the transactions inside without checking those fields. The brothers built their own arrangement of trades, kept the bots’ purchases, swapped the bait orders for sales, and exited before the bots sold. Their validator drew a penalty of about 1 ETH.

Why the judge rejected the fraud theory

Clarke’s 46-page opinion, filed in a New York federal court, described Ethereum as a “trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use.” She held that putting a transaction in the public mempool did not amount to a promise about execution order, and that the false header fields did not matter because the relay never inspected them, so the information had no effect on its recipient.

Rack-mounted Ethereum node server with warning light in a dim server roomAlso readTeku and Besu Strip Emudhra Certificates in ETH Validator Patch

Clarke acknowledged the brothers concealed their intentions and may have gone against the design intent of the relay software, but said conduct can be objectionable without being criminal on the charges filed. The ruling resolves the fraud claims only and does not declare every MEV strategy lawful, and it says nothing about whether the conduct was ethical or broke other laws.

The court also compared the case to the 2025 wire fraud ruling involving Mango Markets trader Avraham Eisenberg, where another judge found insufficient evidence of false representation. Prosecutors did not call an Ethereum trading expert or a witness from Ultrasound at trial, and only one of the three injured sandwich traders testified, crypto.news reported; Savannah Technologies was among those three.

Why it matters

The acquittal closes a case that followed the brothers’ May 2024 arrests after an IRS Criminal Investigation probe, when each of the original three counts carried up to 20 years. For validator operators and MEV searchers, it sets a boundary: failing to follow a relay’s design intent is not automatically fraud. Peter Van Valkenburgh, executive director of Coin Center, told Cointelegraph the outcome was “excellent news,” warning that the prosecution’s honest-validator theory could otherwise let the government impose its own conduct standards on open-network participants.

The reports differ on one framing: Bitcoinist refers to the Ultrasound relay, while crypto.news ties the vulnerability to relay software associated with MEV-Boost; both agree the operation left a $25 million loss for targeted bots.

What to watch

The court clerk’s closure of the case is the immediate step. Beyond it, the opinion is likely to be cited in pending and future MEV disputes, including private litigation such as the Pump.fun class action Cointelegraph has reported on; watch how courts treat mempool submissions as promises, if at all. Clarke’s ruling isn’t a green light to copy the playbook, and these are legal findings rather than a guarantee of future market outcomes or prices. This is not financial advice, and crypto markets are volatile.

Sources: Bitcoinist, crypto.news, Cointelegraph

Written by CryptoNewsInsights Editorial

The CryptoNewsInsights Editorial desk covers Bitcoin, Ethereum, XRP, altcoins and crypto regulation. Our AI-assisted newsroom builds each article from published, linked sources, checks it for accuracy before it goes live, and our editors review published articles and correct anything that needs it.

How we report
More from Ethereum News

This article is for information only and does not constitute financial advice. Cryptocurrency markets are volatile; do your own research before making investment decisions.